Bonefish Bay Motel | Hotel in Marathon, Florida

“This place is a hidden gem in the Keys!! It was clean, well furnished, the staff was pleasant and they had great amenities! Saw several families playing pickleball, we enjoyed the pool and the chairs by the dock. Bathrooms were clean and well stocked, rooms were spacious. The beds in our room were a little tall, but some of the best hotel beds we’ve ever slept on! Wonderful stay, we will definitely be back!”

“Great stay. Clean. Staff very helpful. Bikes, kayaks. Fishing dock. We’ll be back next time in the Keys.”

“The room was very clean and comfortable. Appreciated the free use of kayaks. Dock area was ok but the water not as pretty there as in other parts of marathon. Pretty beaches were close by but has to pay to park. Overall, good value”

“we enjoyed it so much as a grown up trip we are coming back with the kids”

“Overall- yes, I would definitely stay here again. Pros: location was great- plenty of things to do and places to eat nearby. The place was very clean. My husband has a black light on his flashlight and checked out our room- it was incredibly clean. It was on the water and our son was easily able to fish. We didn’t use the kayaks because of the grass/ seaweed that washed up, but they were there and easily accessible. Check in was a breeze. We had a late check in- after midnight- and the staff emailed me letting me know exactly how to check in. The pool was nice too- very clean and deeper than most hotel pools. My son loved that bc he made friends with other kids doing cannonball contests. Cons- there’s no curtain on the window and it’s very bright out. We ended up unscrewing our porch light and that helped some. The beds were squeaky but comfortable. The biggest complaint was the bathroom floor. It’s covered in large tiles that were mostly broken. It was incredibly squeaky and there was a ton of give if you stepped on them. It almost felt like the floor had soft spots.”

“Professionally renovated, very clean, nicely decorated and convenient. Docks were also good.”

“The room was very clean and well maintained. The staff were kind, professional and very helpful. The hotel provided free kayak and bike rental. Will stay at this hotel again when I visit Key West in the future.”

“Great location. Only 1 hour drive to Key West. There is a small kitchenette in the room with dishes, silverware, glasses, coffee maker, small fridge and microwave. Kayaks free of charge. We had to call for maintenance since we wanted to watch a certain football game on a Sunday and they came out right away and helped us. I’d stay here again!”

“Clean room and comfortable bed Pool is very nice and the staff is friendly and helpful ”

“My son and I stayed here on 04/29. We didn’t use much of the room due to FISHING!! But staff was very friendly, rooms were clean, bed was comfortable and the a/c was ice cold! I would definitely stay here again. The property also had cool looking cabins and boat rooms!”